Ad Hoc Digital

AI search for criminal defense

How does a criminal defense lawyer show up in ChatGPT and Google's AI answers?

Someone just arrested asks what to do next, often at night, often on a phone. In our check, the answer quoted a defense firm's step list. Here's how a defense firm earns that spot.

Santiago Alvarez

By , Founder, Ad Hoc Digital
Last updated

The short answer

If you read one part of this page, read this.

A criminal defense firm shows up in AI answers by publishing short, state-specific pages that tell a frightened person what happens next: what to do after an arrest, what a charge means under the statute, what happens at the first court date, and how bail, diversion and record sealing work where the firm practices. Each page answers in its first lines, names the state and county, and links the statute.

Defense is a practice where firm pages already win. When we checked an assault question for Florida on October 18, 2026, the answer at the head of Bing's results quoted a St. Petersburg defense firm's numbered list of first steps. The firms that publish plain steps get quoted; the ones with a generic practice page don't.

This guide covers the questions, the sources, the profiles, the pages to build and the advertising and solicitation rules that apply. It's marketing guidance, not legal advice. We work with law firms across the US and Canada, and also in Australia and the UK.

What people ask

People facing charges search for a lawyer near them and ask how to make the charge go away.

AI tools don't share what people type, so Google's search counts are the nearest public measure. Defense demand is dominated by "near me" searches, with a long tail of urgent questions.

Criminal defense searches in the US, Google Keyword Planner, monthly average, pulled October 18, 2026
What people searchSearches a monthWhat the firm's page has to answer
"criminal defense lawyer" and close wordings165,000Who handles this charge here, and how fast they respond
"criminal defense lawyers near me" and close wordings90,500Which firms are close and answer now
"how to drop charges against someone"880Who decides (the prosecutor, not the victim) and what a victim can do
"how to get a domestic violence charge dropped"320How these cases move, and why talking to the other person can hurt
Criminal defense searches in the US, Google Keyword Planner, monthly average, pulled October 18, 2026 Google pools close wordings, including "attorney" and "lawyer", into one figure. Counts are Google's 12-month averages in its own rounded buckets.

The question searches are small next to the "near me" volume, but they're the ones AI answers handle. A person who asks a full question at 2 a.m. after a relative's arrest is reading, not dialing yet. The firm whose page they read is the one they call at 8. Our criminal defense marketing page covers how these clients pick a lawyer under time pressure.

Which sources get cited

In our check, a defense firm's numbered first-steps list became the answer.

We searched "what should I do if I'm charged with assault in Florida" on Bing, the index Copilot grounds in, on October 18, 2026.

The answer at the head of the page

Bing showed no generated summary this time. Instead its featured answer quoted a St. Petersburg defense firm's page titled "Immediate Steps to Take After a Florida Assault or Battery Arrest", a numbered list of steps.

The results below it

A Florida court-records site citing the assault statute, two other defense firms' sites (Galanter Law and charlespvaughn.com), legal information sites and lawshield.us. Three of the first results came from defense firms, including the quoted one.

The quoted page did three things: it named the state and the charge in the title, it answered in a numbered list, and it put the answer before any sales copy. Google says its AI Overviews and AI Mode build answers from several related searches and link supporting pages, so a set of pages like this, one per charge and stage, gives them material for each sub-question. Our guide to Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode explains how those links are chosen.

Profiles and directories

For defense firms, the Business Profile and reviews do the heavy lifting with people deciding fast.

People facing charges often decide within hours. These are the places AI tools and those people read, and what to do on each.

Where a criminal defense firm's details are read, and what to fix
PlaceWhy it matters for defenseWhat to do
Google Business ProfileFeeds the map and Google's AI answers; shows hours when someone calls at nightCriminal law as the primary category, real hours, after-hours line if you have one
Google reviewsThe main proof a stranger sees; clients rarely leave them unpromptedAsk at case close; let clients review without naming the charge
Avvo, Justia, FindLawLarge legal directories AI tools can read; none appeared in our assault checkClaim, list the charges you take, match details to the site
Your state bar's lawyer searchConfirms license and discipline historySame name as the site and profile
Local court and jail pagesOfficial sources for bond, visiting and court datesLink them from your pages; it makes yours the useful one
Where a criminal defense firm's details are read, and what to fix

Reviews are thin in defense because clients don't want to be associated with a charge. A short ask with a direct link at the end of a good outcome, plus the option to leave initials only, helps. Our Google reviews guide covers the method. Reviews and AI search covers how AI tools read them.

The content to build

A defense firm needs pages for each charge and each stage of a case, written for its state and courts.

This is the order we build in for a criminal defense firm. It follows what a person needs to know from the hour of arrest to the end of the case.

  1. What to do right after an arrest

    A numbered list for the person and one for the family: stay silent, ask for a lawyer, how bond works in your county, how to find someone in the jail. This is the page that gets quoted.

  2. One page per charge you take

    The statute and its number, linked; the degree and the possible penalties as the statute states them; common defenses in plain words; what the first court date looks like.

  3. "Can the victim drop the charges?"

    It's searched hundreds of times a month and the answer is usually no. Explain who decides and what the alleged victim can do, without coaching anyone.

  4. Diversion, sealing and expungement in your state

    Who qualifies, how long it takes and the statute that governs it. Long-tail, high-intent, and often missing from firm sites.

  5. Your courts and your process

    The courthouses you appear in, how fast you respond, what a consultation covers. AI answers about "who" lean on these facts.

  6. A bio for each lawyer

    Admissions, years licensed, prior roles stated accurately ("former assistant state attorney, 2012 to 2018"), and any certification with the certifying body named.

Put the answer first and the call to action after it. Our guide on how to show up in ChatGPT covers the page format, and Google says its AI features need nothing beyond ordinary search guidance. DUI is a separate cluster with its own questions; see our DUI AI search guide.

The ad rules that apply

Defense content is advertising, and contact with arrested people is where solicitation rules bite.

A page anyone can find is advertising. A message sent to a person because you know they were just arrested can be solicitation. These are the traps in defense work.

  • Arrest lists and booking data: the ABA's Formal Opinion 501 makes lawyers responsible for solicitation by their staff and vendors, and one of its examples is calling people from a sheriff's arrest list. Our ABA Model Rules guide covers the opinion; your state may have its own rules on written contact with defendants.
  • Retargeting and custom audiences: Google's personalized advertising policy names criminal defense lawyers as a sensitive category, so defense firms can't use their own audience lists there, and on Meta nothing sensitive may be sent or used to build an audience. Uploading a list of arrested people is a solicitation question as well. Our retargeting rules guide covers what Google and Meta allow.
  • Results: "charges dismissed" and "not guilty" results are true statements that can still create unjustified expectations. Add context, and check your state's disclaimer rule first.
  • "Former prosecutor": allowed if true, and it should say where and when. Don't imply inside influence with a court or an office.
  • "Specialist" and "expert": many states allow "certified" or "specialist" only for lawyers certified by an approved body, with the body named, and others require proof. Check your state's guide before using the word in a profile or page title.

Your own state's rules are in our lawyer advertising rules by state and province. The social media side is in social media rules for lawyers. This is a plain summary for marketing planning, not legal advice. Check the current rule with your bar or law society.

How we run it

We test the arrest-night questions for a firm's county and build the pages the answers are missing.

When we onboard a criminal defense firm for [AI search](/our-services/ai-search), we start with the questions families ask in the first 24 hours.

We write a set of questions the way people phrase them in a panic, for the firm's state and county: what to do after an arrest, bond, the first court date, each charge the firm wants, "can the charges be dropped". We ask them of ChatGPT, Google's AI features, Gemini, Perplexity and Copilot, note which sources are cited and whether the firm is named, and repeat the same set on a schedule. The short version is in our self-check guide.

Defense firms usually pair this with paid search for the "near me" volume. One defense firm we work with hit record months three weeks in. Another firm handling family and criminal cases signed its first client hours after launch. The pages that answer the arrest-night questions support those ads, because people check a firm before they call.

Common mistakes

Where firms go wrong.

The AI search mistakes we see most on criminal defense sites.

  1. A generic "criminal defense" page

    One page can't answer what to do after an arrest, what a charge carries and how sealing works. Each needs its own page.

  2. Sales copy before the answer

    "Facing charges? Call now" at the start of a page gives AI tools nothing to quote. Put the steps first.

  3. No statute numbers

    A charge page without the statute and its penalties reads as an ad. Link the statute on the legislature's site.

  4. Overstated results

    A wall of "dismissed" headlines without context invites a rules problem and sets expectations a new client may not meet.

  5. Hours that don't match reality

    If the profile says open and nobody answers at night, the person calls the next firm. Match listed hours to who picks up.

Real results

What this looked like for real firms.

Defense firms we work with, and what changed when the marketing started working.

$13,500 Generated From Just $600 in Advertising Spend.
Google Local Services AdsDUI Defense · Criminal Defense

$13,500

Had tried SEO, PPC, social, lead vendors, nothing worked. 12 days with us turned it around.

Read the full story

Identifying details are anonymized to protect our clients. Individual result, not a promise or prediction of any specific outcome for your firm.

See every case study

FAQ

Questions lawyers ask us.

Straight answers to the questions that come up most.

Do people really ask ChatGPT what to do after an arrest?

They ask AI tools and search engines exactly that, often for a relative and often at night. The answer they read shapes which firm they call in the morning.

Why did a firm page get quoted in our check?

It named the state and charge in its title, answered in a numbered list and put the answer before any sales copy. That's a format any defense firm can copy for each charge it handles.

Is it solicitation to write about a case in the news?

A general article is advertising. Sending it, or a message about it, to the accused or their family because you know about the arrest can be solicitation. Check your state's rules on written contact first.

Should defense firms publish case results?

Many do, and the rules generally allow true results with context. A results page full of dismissals without explanation can mislead, and some states require a disclaimer. Check your state's guide.

Which directories matter for defense lawyers?

The Google Business Profile and reviews first, then the large legal directories such as Avvo, Justia and FindLaw. Keep every profile identical to your website.

Can I use arrest records to target ads?

Treat it as a solicitation question first. The ABA's Opinion 501 uses calling people from a sheriff's arrest list as an example of solicitation the lawyer answers for, and Google doesn't let criminal defense advertisers use their own audience lists at all, as our retargeting guide explains. Broad local ads are the safer route.

How is AI search measured for a defense firm?

By asking the same questions on a schedule and recording whether the firm is named, and by adding an AI option to "how did you hear about us". Our guide to measuring AI search traffic covers the details.

Where we do this

The services this guide touches.

What this looks like when we run it for a firm, with a demo for your practice on each page.

ServiceAI searchGetting your firm named when people ask ChatGPT, Google's AI answers, Gemini or Copilot who to hire.Learn moreServiceLocal Services AdsThe Google Verified listings above the regular results. You pay per lead, and Google credits back poor-quality leads.Learn moreServiceGoogle AdsSearch ads for the exact case types you want, with landing pages built to get the call.Learn more

Sources

Where these facts come from.

Official pages we read when writing this page. Platforms and rules change, so check the current version before you act on any of it. This is marketing guidance, not legal advice.

Santiago Alvarez

Written by

Santiago Alvarez

Founder of Ad Hoc Digital. Leads strategy and works directly with every client firm on AI search, Local Services Ads, Google Ads and Meta ads.

More about Santiago

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

Book a free 30-minute call. Tell us how cases come in today, and we'll tell you straight what we'd change, and whether we can help.

Schedule a Consultation